Old Mill Creamery, LLC | Authentic Homemade Ice Cream & Waffles in Mifflinburg, PA

Old Mill Creamery offers more than delicious ice cream--it's an experience. The environment is perfect for family relaxation, with a lovely creek on the property providing both soothing background sounds and entertainment for children. This location also has a drive-through for easy access. All of the employees are polite and the ice cream scoops are generous. They also offer tasty coffee drinks. Our family has found every visit to be an all-around treat.

Excellent service and ice-cream! I got a home made waffle cone that was delicious. We sat down by the pretty little creek(Buffalo Creek I think) They also have a great selection of milks, cheeses, and roasted coffee!

Old Mill Creamery is a delightful stop near Lewisburg that combines rich history with delicious treats! This family-owned business has its roots in a local farm, which adds a special touch to the ice cream they serve. The creamery has a charming atmosphere that reflects its historical background, making it a great place for a nostalgic visit. We absolutely loved the ice cream; it was creamy and full of flavor, with a variety of unique options to choose from. In addition to their fantastic ice cream, they also offer specialty items for sale, including locally sourced products that showcase the best of the region. It also has a drive thru! The friendly staff made our experience even better, welcoming us with smiles and sharing the story of their family business. It’s clear that they take pride in their craft and the community they serve. Overall, Old Mill Creamery is a must visit for anyone in the area looking for a sweet treat and a taste of local history!

This place is great! From the moment we arrived we smelled fresh waffles being made for their waffle cones. The ice cream is incredible with a lot of variety. They also have a lot of nice local food options and a peaceful outdoor seating area along a stream.

Old Mill Creamery sets the gold standard for what an ice cream experience should be. Each visit proves their consistency in quality, with classic flavors executed flawlessly and inventive seasonal varieties that keep things exciting. The staff is warm and welcoming, and the space itself is spotless—an inviting environment for families and solo visitors alike. The homemade waffle cones deserve special mention. I’ve never been a waffle cone enthusiast, yet Old Mill Creamery has changed my mind entirely. The aroma of freshly pressed cones fills the shop, and the taste is every bit as captivating as the scent—crispy, buttery, and the perfect complement to their rich ice creams. Old Mill Creamery doesn’t just serve ice cream; it delivers an experience that redefines what we expect from a creamery. This is the benchmark against which all others should be measured.

Great service and the ice cream is delicious. What’s more there is an outdoor eating area right by a picturesque creek named Rapid Run. You can’t go wrong here. Good selection of ice cream flavors, fancy coffee and massive cones. Homemade potato chips are fun extra item. Also, pints and half gallons of ice cream are available for carry out. Worth the drive in off I-80. Will be back!

Do yourself a favor and please stop here! The ice cream is delicious, and there are so many delicious flavors to choose from! I’ve tried the chocolate espresso, salted caramel pretzel, mint chocolate chip, and peanut butter brownie ice creams and all were FANTASTIC. They make their own waffle cones in house, so it always smells fantastic in there and the waffle cones are out of this world! The coffee is also delicious - I love getting the affagato!

By far the best tasting and quality ice cream in the area. The waffle cones are incredible and made in house. You can smell them as soon as you walk in. So so tasty. There is a lovely creek with ample seating you can sit by to enjoy your treats. Def looking forward to coming back to try other flavors and a latte in the future.