Old Mill Creamery, LLC Menu

Old Mill Creamery, LLC in Mifflinburg, PA, offers an exceptional ice cream experience rooted in family tradition and local charm. Their homemade waffle cones are freshly pressed, buttery, and crispy, perfectly complementing the rich, creamy ice cream inside. The vanilla flavor stands out for its pure, smooth taste, while the unique cheese-infused varieties highlight the creamery’s farm-to-table heritage.

The serene setting beside Buffalo Creek enhances every visit, creating a peaceful retreat with soothing natural sounds and a welcoming outdoor seating area. Families appreciate the relaxed environment and generous scoops, while the friendly staff adds warmth to the experience.

Beyond ice cream, the creamery offers locally sourced cheeses, milks, and roasted coffees, making it a standout spot for regional flavors. Whether you visit the drive-thru or sit by the creek, Old Mill Creamery delivers more than dessert—it promises a memorable taste of history and community in every bite.